Skip to main content

The Emirates Times

Linkedin Twitter Facebook Tumblr

The Emirates Times

– Make It Happen
Enquire Now
Menu
  • HOME
  • INTERVIEW
  • UAE
  • GULF NEWS
    • Dubai
    • Jordan
    • Bahrain
    • Abu Dhabi
    • Saudi Arabia
    • Oman
  • BUSINESS
  • TECHNOLOGY
  • LIFESTYLE
  • EVENT
  • SUCCESS STORIES
  • METAVERSE

The Emirates Times

– Make It Happen
Menu
  • Home
  • Interview
  • UAE
  • Gulf News
    • BUSINESS
    • Dubai
    • Jordan
    • Saudi Arabia
    • Abu Dhabi
    • Bahrain
    • Oman
  • Technology
  • Lifestyle
    • EVENT
  • Metaverse
Home Health

Who Is Liable When AI Gets a Diagnosis Wrong? Dubai’s Health Chief Explains

November 19, 2026
in Health, Transport
0 0
1
Who Is Liable When AI Gets a Diagnosis Wrong? Dubai’s Health Chief Explains

Who Is Liable When AI Gets a Diagnosis Wrong? Dubai’s Health Chief Explains

As hospitals around the world adopt artificial intelligence, one question keeps coming up in patients’ minds: if the software gets it wrong, who is to blame? Dubai’s top health official gave his answer this week, and it is not a simple one.

Dr Alawi Alsheikh-Ali, Director General of the Dubai Health Authority (DHA), said responsibility depends on how the technology is used. Speaking at the AI Retreat during Dubai Future Week, in a session titled “Past the Pilot,” he said no single party carries the blame automatically.

Table of Contents

Toggle
  • Three possible answers
  • Patients should know when AI is involved
  • Earlier detection is not always better
  • A risk-based approach
  • The biggest prize: time
  • What this means for patients in Dubai

Three possible answers

Alsheikh-Ali named three candidates for responsibility: the doctor, the hospital that allowed the technology into its wards, and the company that built it. He then separated two situations.

In the first, AI acts as a tool that helps a doctor. In the second, it acts as the care provider itself. On the second, he said the health system is not yet at that point.

Where AI assists, he said, the physician carries responsibility, because a human provides oversight and makes the final decision. If the product itself is defective, some liability shifts to the developer. A hospital that lets staff use AI without proper vetting, monitoring or training may share the burden. He conceded the answer is not straightforward, but said it is probably a shared responsibility.

Patients should know when AI is involved

Alsheikh-Ali also stressed that patients should be told when AI plays a part in their diagnosis. He illustrated how subtle clinical judgement can be with an example from the consulting room.

A doctor asks a patient whether he has chest pain. In one version the patient says no and means it. In another he says no, but his expression suggests otherwise. In a third, his wife interrupts to say he is in denial again. An ambient AI tool that transcribes consultations would record the same word each time. As he put it, the “no” is not the same in those three cases. Such tools are already used in the United States, and the question he posed was where AI captures human judgement and where it does not.

Earlier detection is not always better

He also offered a cautionary example from cancer screening. A new technology might detect a certain cancer six months earlier than current methods, which sounds like an obvious win. But when researchers ran a proper study, they found the tool also flagged findings that were not cancer. That meant extra tests and more anxious patients. Catching the disease earlier, meanwhile, did not change the final outcome.

His conclusion was straightforward. The test for any AI tool should be whether it brings real value to the patient by improving care, saving cost or saving time. He dismissed marketing as a measure, noting that telling people a hospital uses AI may make it look modern, but that brings no benefit to the patient.

A risk-based approach

Rather than asking whether AI should be allowed, Alsheikh-Ali prefers to ask what must be known before it is allowed in. Low-risk uses can face lighter criteria, and high-risk uses should face tougher ones. Any new tool, he said, should make care better, safer or more efficient, for instance by treating more patients at the same level of safety.

Today’s strongest uses, in his view, sit in operations and pattern recognition. These include note summaries and the reading of X-rays, CT scans, MRIs and skin or heart readings. He also sees promise in drug discovery, where AI could shorten the time needed to identify new targets.

The biggest prize: time

Perhaps the most striking part of his argument was about doctors’ time. Clinicians lose many hours to paperwork. If AI gives that time back, he suggested, it could restore the human touch to medicine, letting doctors spend more of each day with patients and less with screens.

What this means for patients in Dubai

For patients, the message is a reassuring one in some respects. A human doctor remains responsible for the final decision when AI is used as an aid, which means there is a clear person to ask about a diagnosis. At the same time, the DHA chief’s admission that the rules around shared liability are still evolving shows that this is an area where regulators and the courts will continue to work things out.

Patients who are uncertain about whether AI has been used in their care can ask their provider directly. The DHA’s position that people should know when AI plays a role gives that question a firm footing.

The discussion also reflects the wider theme of Dubai Future Week, where the question is less about what technology can do and more about how it should be governed, and who answers for it when things go wrong.

Next Article

Tags: AI cancer screeningAI diagnosis errorsAI in healthcare UAEAI misdiagnosis liabilityAI Retreatambient AI doctorsdoctor responsibility AIDr Alawi Alsheikh-AliDubai Future WeekDubai Health AuthorityDubai healthcare demandhealthcare technology UAEmedical AI accountabilitypatient safety Dubai
ShareTweetSend
Next Post
Dubai Future Week Puts the Human Question at the Centre of the AI Debate

Dubai Future Week Puts the Human Question at the Centre of the AI Debate

Comments 1

  1. Pingback: Dubai Future Week Puts The Human Question At The Centre Of The AI Debate - The Emirates Times
No Result
View All Result

Latest Posts

Dubai Future Week Puts the Human Question at the Centre of the AI Debate
Technology

Dubai Future Week Puts the Human Question at the Centre of the AI Debate

by Rohan Kumar
November 19, 2026
0

Dubai has spent years describing itself as a city that builds the future rather than waits for it. This week,...

Read more
Who Is Liable When AI Gets a Diagnosis Wrong? Dubai’s Health Chief Explains

Who Is Liable When AI Gets a Diagnosis Wrong? Dubai’s Health Chief Explains

November 19, 2026
Dubai Gold Slides Below Dh450 a Gram as Global Prices Hit 14-Month Low

Dubai Gold Slides Below Dh450 a Gram as Global Prices Hit 14-Month Low

November 19, 2026
Glowing Blue Waves Light Up UAE Beaches as Rare Bioluminescence Draws Crowds to Fujairah

Glowing Blue Waves Light Up UAE Beaches as Rare Bioluminescence Draws Crowds to Fujairah

November 19, 2026
UAE Has Shut Down 600,000 Websites and Ads in Wildlife Trafficking Crackdown

UAE Has Shut Down 600,000 Websites and Ads in Wildlife Trafficking Crackdown

November 19, 2026

Follow Us

The Emirates Times

– Make It Happen
The Emirates Times is an English Language Internet media with a significant focus on business, technology, news, entrepreneurship, leadership, innovation, prominent business personalities, and many more, majorly in the GCC region. Further, the company publishes interviews, news, business content, press releases, etc. This platform also publishes about real estate, sports, metaverse, business ideas, and more.
Linkedin Twitter Facebook Tumblr

Important links

  • HOME
  • INTERVIEW
  • UAE
  • GULF NEWS
  • TECHNOLOGY
  • LIFESTYLE
  • METAVERSE

Contact Us

  • sales@theemiratestimes.com
  • +91-70-6556-6556

© 2024 theemiratestimes